What kind of women become five-star female members?

Maezawa from the CEO’s office here, and I’ll answer this too. It’s helpful that Kazu has laid out the criteria. They are indeed based on those standards. However, when it comes to how they’re actually applied: > 1. When the response to messages from staff is prompt > If almost all replies arrive within two hours and are written politely, the rating goes up by one star. How much is “almost all”? 80%? 90%? After how many replies can this be applied? (One reply isn’t enough, right?) Because of questions like these, it rarely gets applied. As for point 2, men are often slow to submit feedback. Some even intentionally leave bad reviews so that other men won’t make offers, because they want to keep a particularly great woman all to themselves. (笑) So it’s rare to receive three positive feedbacks. With point 3, there’s also some doubt as to whether they really check everyone’s feedback. For these reasons, reaching five stars seems quite difficult. I also seem to remember that the criteria for moving up were discussed by the managers.

I’m だて◎ゆめ, a male member. I agree with 紙ひこうき! > I wonder whether this really qualifies as good papa-katsu. I think that pretty much sums it up, especially that line. Relationships vary from person to person and depend on each individual’s outlook, but I think the important thing is to make sure it’s enjoyable, not forced, and mutually beneficial—rather than focusing on the number of stars. If that results in a five-star rating, all the better.

I’m Taro, a male member. I wonder if many men decide whether to make an offer based on the star ratings. I personally never paid much attention to them. I looked at the women I’ve made offers to in the past who are still active members, and not a single one of them had gained any stars. In my experience, women whose ratings went up tended to be “calculating,” while those with fewer stars tended to be “awkward.” So I may actually feel more favorably toward women with fewer stars.

I’m a male member, “Paper Airplane.” Here are my thoughts on a five-star woman. From the conversation the moment we met until we said goodbye, she was absolutely flawless. She’s practically a model club member. I’m sure the club staff can recommend her with complete confidence. Once someone earns five stars, it’s almost like their monthly offers are guaranteed. Every aspect of her would pass muster, and I can’t imagine receiving any negative feedback from men. Her attitude toward the allowance is also the complete opposite of being money-hungry—she’s exceptionally reasonable. Since feedback with that kind of money-focused attitude would make it difficult to earn five stars... We still see each other occasionally, and even when there are long gaps between messages, the relationship never fades. The fact that she can maintain such a good relationship is impressive. That said, as someone mentioned in a previous question, being too good or too perfect doesn’t necessarily mean the satisfaction level is high. I sometimes feel that this is more of a successful papa-katsu (compensated dating in Japan) arrangement than a genuinely fulfilling relationship.

I’m Kazu, a male member. As Maezawa explained in his answer here: https://universe-club.jp/help/questions/view/1166 —Quoted text— Cases where a rating is increased: 1. When you respond promptly to messages from staff If nearly all replies arrive within two hours and are written politely, we increase the rating by one star. 2. When you consistently receive good feedback If we receive positive feedback three or more times in a row regarding your manners, attitude, and so on, we increase the rating by one star. (However, this only applies if there is no negative feedback serious enough to warrant lowering the rating by one star.) 3. When you continue having dates without any particular problems If you have five or more dates without being late, canceling, or changing the schedule, we increase the rating by one star. —End quote— So, if you receive offers and continue getting good feedback and going on dates without any problems, your number of stars gradually increases. I’m not sure whether I’m allowed to mention the number, so I’ll leave that out, but more women than I expected had a five-star rating.