Female members with five stars in the C category don’t seem to be viewed very favorably, but how do female members perceive male members (Black members) with five stars?

I think it would be better to remove the five-star cap for male members. I’m currently at five stars, but I’m confident I’d actually be over ten by now. Maybe five stars could be Sergeant, ten could be Major, twenty could be Major General, and fifty could be General? Four stars would be Private First Class, and three or fewer would be Private. Wouldn’t “Black General” or “Platinum Major” be fun? lol

There’s no question that female members with more stars are generally viewed more favorably than those with fewer. Men who say they don’t like five-star women usually don’t dislike the high rating itself—they simply don’t like women who have gone on dates with a lot of men. Men are, by nature, generally drawn to newcomers and women who seem inexperienced. Women, on the other hand, tend to focus on different things: whether he treats other people kindly, whether he behaves like a gentleman toward restaurant staff, and so on. That’s why they may be wary of men with few stars. A woman who has just joined might also assume, in the same way she would with a site like Tabelog, that a man with lots of stars must be a good person. But they soon realize that many five-star men are awful, too, and stop caring about the number of stars. In other words, I think many women see a five-star man and feel nothing in particular. Ideally, five-star men would live up to their ratings, but that doesn’t seem to happen very often.

It probably won’t give a bad impression. The woman will likely assume that the women he had received offers from up to that point had a good impression of him. I don’t think most women overanalyze things the way men do. It’s hard for women to imagine a world where men send out a ridiculous number of offers—let alone pay money to do so… The same applies to men, too. If they don’t need to send offers and their relationship continues, or if they’ve just joined, they’re still rated ★3. So in that sense, there’s a slight similarity with women. Just like women, their rating will go up once they’ve sent out a certain number of offers.