I’m a man in my 50s who joined a year and a half ago. I’m somewhat hesitant about making an offer to a woman in her 30s who has been registered for over five years and has a five-star rating. I recently saw a question from someone interested in a woman with zero stars and could relate to it, but at the same time, I’m also curious about women who have a perfect rating at the club. Has anyone here made an offer to someone with a perfect rating? If so, I’d appreciate hearing your impressions for reference. Thank you.

I’m a male member who goes by “Paper Airplane.” I can’t speak to her recent reviews, but based on my experience with her previous five-star ratings: She’s exactly what you’d expect from a five-star rating. If I were a staff member, I could recommend her without any hesitation. From a male member’s perspective, she has no real shortcomings and is virtually faultless. That said, if you ask whether I’d continue seeing her or add her to my favorites, I’d say she’s almost too safe—perhaps a little too accustomed to the club. For men who prefer someone who isn’t used to the club scene, she probably wouldn’t be a regular choice. Meeting her occasionally, though, is perfectly nice.

I’m in Seattle. Two years ago, I made an offer to someone with a perfect rating. They spoke politely and modestly, and seemed to be seeing around ten people at the same time.